Grand Admiral Revil wrote:However, the Federation is usually shown as inept, incompetent, and corrupt, never as outright malicious.
Zeta Gundam would like a word with you. Okay, it was the Titans doing all the evil work but who was it that gave a bunch of psychopaths total authority and absolutely no oversight to begin with? Plus, they're technically part of the Federation even if they're basically a law unto themselves. I seem to recall a fair degree of malice in Silhouette Formula as well. F91's shooting up a captured colony full of civilians to try and kill the enemy leadership was pretty malicious too, not to mention incompetent seeing how they
missed.
I have a feeling this is done mostly to make Neo Zeon look like a bunch of brave, noble 'freedom fighters', while ignoring the fact that they're essentially a bunch of mass murdering terrorist who just 3 years prior (in-universe) tried to exterminate all life on earth!
Not that I'm defending what Char tried to do but technically his goal wasn't to end all life on earth, it was to get everyone to move
off the earth. The fact that a lot of people would have died and the theory Char was basing his plan on (basically everything his dad thought about Newtypes) appears to have been wrong don't change that.